| Basic
Definitions: Q:
What is a trademark?
A: A trademark is a word, name, symbol, device or
combination used to identify
and distinguish the source of the goods of one party from those of
others.
Q:
What is a service mark?
A: A service mark is a word, name, symbol, device or
combination used to
identify and distinguish the source of the services of one party
from those of others.
Q:
What is the difference between a Trade Name and a Trademark?
A: A trade name is used to identify a business. However, the trade name
may also be used as a trademark to identify products or as a service
mark to identify services.
In
other words: Trademarks identify products; Service
marks identify services; Trade names identify
businesses.
Initial
Considerations:
Q:
How are trademark rights established?
A: In the United States, trademark rights are created
through actual use of a trademark. However, as of
1989, a trademark may be reserved by filing an Intent
to Use trademark application prior to actual use.
Q:
What is the difference between state registration and federal
registration of a trademark?
A: State trademark registration is not recommended because trademark law
in the United States is controlled by federal statute (the Lanham
Act).
Q:
What are the advantages in registering a trademark at the United States
Patent and Trademark Office?
A: An issued U.S. trademark registration can provide priority to the
trademark owner against all users of conflicting marks who had not used
the conflicting mark before the filing date of the trademark owner's
application. For this reason, it is very important to prepare and file a
trademark application as soon as possible. A U.S. registration also
provides the following benefits: evidence that the trademark is valid
and that the owner of the registration is the owner of the valid
registration, evidence of continued use of the mark since the filing
date of the application, incontestible status after five (5) years which
prevents an attack of the registration on the grounds of prior use by
others or that the trademark is descriptive, the right to sue an
infringer, statutory damages which can include up to three
times the actual money damages
and the ability to bar the importation of infringing imports at U.S.
Customs entry ports.
Selection
of a Trademark:
Q:
Is the selection of a trademark important from the
standpoint of registration and protection?
A: Yes. It is much better to start with a strong
trademark
that is not confusingly similar to other existing trademark
registrations or applications. This improves the
probability that the application will not be encounter
difficulties at the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office
and also provides the owner with a trademark that is
easier to protect from would be infringers.
Q:
How do you know if a trademark is strong?
A: Trademarks are classified into four (4) categories, in order of
increasing strength:
| Category: |
Definition: |
Example: |
Comments:
|
| 1. Generic
|
The common name for the kind of product -- can never
become a protectable trademark.
|
Automobile, consumer electronics (magazine
title)
|
Rational: The public has a fundamental right to the
use of all generic terms.
|
| 2.Descriptive
|
A term which describes something about the product or
service -- can be protected if secondary meaning is
established.
|
Super Steel Radial, Hoagie, Video Buyer's Guide,
Quick Print
|
Secondary meaning requires proof that the relevant
purchasing public associates the term with a single source.
|
| 3.Suggestive
|
A term that subtly suggests something about the
product or service -- can be protected immediately upon use.
|
habitat (for home furnishings), skinvisible (for
transparent medical adhesive tape), orange crush (for
beverage)
|
Generally
requires purchaser to exercise some imagination to determine
product or service. |
4.Arbitrary/
Fanciful
|
A
term that bears little or no relationship to the product or service
– Immediately protectable.
|
Arbitrary:
Horizon (for banking services), Tide (for laundry
detergent)
Fanciful: Kodak, Rolex, Exxon, Motorola
|
If no prior conflicting or similar marks, arbitrary
or fanciful mark will be the strongest possible mark.
|
Although either an arbitrary or fanciful mark may be
equally strong, there is a slight difference between
the two classifications. An arbitrary mark is an
ordinary term applied to a good or service in a
totally arbitrary or non-descriptive manner. A
fanciful mark is a made-up term that does not have any
dictionary meaning.
Costs
for the Registration of a Trademark:
Q:
What does it cost to register a trademark with the
U.S. Patent and Trademark Office?
A: It costs $1700. to place a trademark
application in a single class on file with the U.S.
Patent and Trademark Office. This includes a search of
the federal trademark records, registrability opinion
fees, attorney fees for application preparation and
filing and government filing fees. The search can be
extended to include nationwide telephone directories,
trade name sources and state trademark registers. If a
full manual search is not conducted, the application may be filed for
$1,000.00, including the government filing fee.
A
current Schedule of Services and Expenses for Trademarks is available
here.
Q:
What other costs are involved with obtaining a
trademark registration?
A: If the trademark examining attorney decides that
the proposed trademark is confusingly similar to
another existing trademark registration or
application, then additional legal fees to respond to
the examining attorney may be required.
Q:
What is the best way to improve the probability that a
trademark application will not encounter difficulties
after filing with the U.S. Patent and Trademark
Office?
A: The best strategy is to select a strong trademark
that is not confusingly similar to any other existing
trademark registration or pending trademark
application.
Preserving
the Rights in a Trademark:
Q:
What steps must be taken to preserve the rights in an
existing trademark registration?
A: First, the trademark must not be abandoned. It must
be used continuously and the mark must be affixed to
the goods (or tags or packaging) or displayed in
association with the services. An affidavit of
continuous use must be filed during the fifth year
after the registration issues. An affidavit of five
years of continuous use should also be filed to
establish incontestible rights to the trademark. The
trademark registration should then be renewed every
ten (10) years thereafter.
Q:
Are there any special ways that a trademark should be used?
A: Yes. A trademark should always be used as an adjective, and never as a
noun. In other words, the trademark should always be accompanied with a
generic term. For example, Kleenex is used together with the generic term
tissue. Xerox is used together with the generic term copier. Better yet is
to include the term “brand” between the trademark and the generic
term. Hence, Xerox brand copying machine. The consequence of not using (or
educating the public) is that the trademark can be forever lost to the
public domain as a generic term. Examples of generic terms that once were
trademarks are: aspirin, escalator and yo-yo.
Selection
and Use of a Trademark:
Q:
What is the proper way to designate a trademark?
A: Prior to registration, a trademark may be
designated with the superscript TM, and a
service mark with the superscript SM. After
a federal registration has issued, the trademark or
service mark may be designated with the registration
symbol ®.
The
Federal Registration Process:
Q:
Are there different types of trademark applications?
A: Yes. A trademark application may be filed as a use
based application or as an Intent to Use Application.
Q:
What are the requirements for filing a use based
trademark application?
A: First, the trademark must have been actually used
in interstate commerce. Second, three (3) specimens of
the trademark as actually used must be provided.
Third, a drawing of the mark must be provided for a
design trademark. Fourth, the application and
corresponding filing fee must be provided.
Q:
What are the requirements for filing an intent to use
trademark application?
A: If you honestly plan to use a trademark in the
future, you can reserve the use of the trademark by
filing an intent to use trademark application. You
must actually use the trademark in interstate commerce
before a federal registration will issue. It is
possible, however, to postpone the filing of the proof
of use after the application has been approved by the
U.S. Patent and Trademark Office.
Q:
How are trademarks classified?
A: Trademarks are classified into 41 numerical international
classifications based generally upon the type of goods or services. For
example, International Class 9 includes scientific instruments while
International Class 35 includes advertising and business.
Q:
Can a trademark application be filed in more than one class?
A: Yes, but there is an additional government filing fee required for each
additional classification. In many cases, it is preferable to file a
separate application for each appropriate classification.
Q:
What happens to the trademark application after it has been filed?
A: The application is assigned to a trademark examining attorney who
examines the application to determine whether it is confusingly similar to
any existing trademark registrations or pending applications.
Q:
How do you know if a proposed trademark is confusingly
similar to another trademark?
A: There are several factors which are evaluated to
determine likely confusion, which is also the test
used to determine whether one trademark is infringing
another (See infringement below).
In general, the examining attorney considers similarity in
spelling, sound and appearance.
Q:
What happens if the trademark examining attorney
decides that the mark is confusingly similar to
another mark?
A: The applicant or the applicant's attorney is
notified that registration of the mark is refused. The
examining attorney provides an official action which
includes the trademark registration(s) and/or pending
trademark application(s) that are the cause of the
conflict. If the applicant or the applicant's attorney
believe that the examining attorney's position in not
well founded, a response to the refusal may be filed.
Q:
How long does it usually take for a trademark
registration to issue after filing?
A: Presently, it takes approximately 18 months from
the date of filing for a trademark registration to
issue. The goal set by the Trademark Branch of the
U.S. Patent and Trademark Office is to reduce the time
period to 13 months.
International
Protection:
Q:
Is it possible to register a trademark
internationally?
A: At this time, and with certain exceptions, it is
not possible for a U.S. citizen to file an
international trademark application. Legislation is
pending whereby the United States may become a member
of the Madrid Agreement. If this happens, then new
international application options should become
available.
Q:
How are trademarks protected internationally?
A: Foreign associates are generally used in each of
the foreign countries of interest to assist with the
clearance, filing and enforcement of the trademark.
Q:
What is the typical cost for registering a trademark
in a foreign country?
A: The average cost to put a trademark application on
file in a foreign country is $1,500 per mark, per
classification.
Trademark
Infringement:
Q:
What exactly, is meant by trademark infringement?
A: Trademark infringement occurs when a later used
trademark is confusingly similar to an earlier used
trademark. The following factors are evaluated to
determine whether the two marks are confusingly
similar:
*
The strength of plaintiff's mark;
*
The degree of similarity between plaintiff's and
defendant's marks;
*
The proximity of the products or services;
*
The likelihood that the plaintiff will bridge the gap;
*
Defendant's good faith in adopting the mark;
*
Evidence of actual confusion;
*
The sophistication of the buyers; and
*
The quality of defendant's products or services.
Q:
How are rights determined if neither trademark has been registered
at the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office?
A: Absent Federal registration, trademark rights in
the United States are established through use. It is
possible for two (or more) users to use the identical
mark on identical goods if each user occupies mutually
exclusive geographic market areas. Obviously, this can
and does cause problems when one of the users attempts
to expand its business. The best way to avoid the
conflict is to clear the mark and then register it
with the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office.
Q:
What actions should be taken if a trademark owner believes that its
trademark is being infringed?
A: Usually, a letter is sent to the alleged infringer informing them to
discontinue the use of the infringing mark. If this is not successful, a
lawsuit may need to be filed in the appropriate Federal District Court.
The decision whether or not to file a lawsuit will depend primarily upon
the value of the mark and the probability of successfully prevailing at
trial.
Q:
What is the best way to improve the probability of successfully prevailing
at a trademark infringement trial.
A: Although a descriptive mark which has established secondary meaning
through extensive marketing and promotion can be strong, usually the
strongest marks are arbitrary or fanciful.
Proceed
to Application for
Trademark Registration
NOTE:
Because of the complexities, risks and potential rewards involved with
intellectual property matters, it is strongly recommended that you seek
the advice of an intellectual property attorney to assist you with your
creative developments. |